"This Is Us" producer Dan Fogelman reunites with Sterling K. Brown in "Paradise," a "Lost"-like mystery box that can't deliver on its high concept.

Watching Hulu’s new thriller Paradise is a bit like eating a hot fudge sundae served on top of a chocolate cake: It’s a little messy and almost too much at times… but it’s hard to deny that it’s pretty damn delicious,

It’s a show that falls apart the more you look at it, no matter how much its capable cast tries to hold it together.